Business Law

How Does LLC Ownership Work?

What does it really mean to own an LLC? LLCs provide unique opportunities to customize business ownership to fit the particular needs and circumstances of the owners. Here is what you should know about LLC ownership.
LLC Ownership

If you’re forming an LLC, or you already hold an interest in one, your paperwork may identify you as a “member.” But being a member does not, by itself, answer every question about your ownership. Your ownership structure can determine your economic rights, voting power, access to information, and role in managing the business. Your operating agreement and articles of organization, together with applicable state law, help determine how those rights are divided.

What Does It Mean to Own an LLC?

LLC owners are called members. A member can be an individual, trust, or business entity, depending on the circumstances and the governing documents. An LLC with one owner is a single-member LLC; an LLC with two or more is a multi-member LLC.

Holding a “membership interest” means you hold a bundle of rights defined by the LLC’s articles of organization, its operating agreement, and state law where the agreement is silent. That’s different from running the business; you can own a substantial piece of an LLC and have little say in daily operations, or you can manage a company without any ownership stake. Ownership and control are related, but they aren’t the same thing. Understanding that distinction helps you evaluate what your LLC interest actually involves.

How LLC Ownership Is Divided

Most LLCs divide ownership in one of two ways: by percentage or by membership units.

Percentages are simple and familiar. Two founders might each hold 50 percent, or three owners might split ownership 45, 35, and 20 percent based on their agreement.

Membership units can also represent ownership interests. Instead of identifying each member’s interest only by a percentage, the LLC can establish a number of units and specify how those units relate to each member’s ownership. The governing documents can also address how the LLC may issue or transfer additional units as the ownership structure changes.

Neither approach is inherently better than the other. What matters is that the LLC’s governing documents clearly establish how ownership is measured and how it can change over time. Unclear ownership terms matter most when a member wants to transfer an interest, a member dies, or the owners disagree about the business.

What Rights Come With LLC Ownership?

LLC ownership involves several types of rights and responsibilities, including economic, voting, information, and management rights. It’s worth thinking about them separately rather than assuming they work together.

Economic rights. The operating agreement or articles of organization can establish how profits, losses, and distributions are allocated. If those documents do not provide otherwise, Virginia law generally allocates profits, losses, and distributions based on the value of members’ contributions as reflected in the LLC’s records.

Voting rights. Under Virginia’s default rules, members generally vote in proportion to their contributions, and a majority of the voting power is generally required for member action unless the articles of organization or operating agreement provides otherwise. See Va. Code § 13.1-1022 for more details.  

Information rights. These may include the right to inspect the LLC’s books and records and to receive information reasonably necessary to protect your interests.

Management rights. These may include authority to act on the LLC’s behalf, such as signing contracts, hiring employees, and making day-to-day decisions.

Can Ownership and Profit Sharing Be Different?

Yes. Contributions, ownership percentages, and profit distributions don’t have to be structured the same way. The members can establish different arrangements in the governing documents, subject to applicable law.

Take two people starting a business together. One contributes $100,000 in startup capital. The other contributes no cash but works full-time building the company for two years before drawing a salary. Their operating agreement could give the cash contributor a priority return of that $100,000 before any profits are split, move to a 50/50 ownership and distribution split once that happens, and still give both members an equal vote on major decisions from day one.

 

 

Cash-contributing member

Sweat-equity member

Ownership

50%

50%

Voting power

Equal vote

Equal vote

Distributions

Priority return of agreed contribution, then 50/50

50/50 after priority return

Management role

Set by governing documents

Set by governing documents

 

These categories do not necessarily have to match one another. The governing documents should clearly establish how the arrangement will work, subject to applicable law.

How members receive money from an LLC can also have tax consequences. The treatment may depend on the LLC’s tax classification, the nature of the payment, and the member’s circumstances. Because those issues are tax-specific, consider reviewing compensation and distribution arrangements with a qualified tax professional before finalizing the structure.

Who Controls the LLC?

LLCs can be structured so that members manage the business, managers have management responsibility, or management authority is divided as provided in the governing documents.

In a member-managed LLC, members generally participate in managing the business and may have authority to act on the LLC’s behalf, subject to the articles of organization, operating agreement, and applicable law.

In a manager-managed LLC, authority is concentrated in one or more designated managers, who may or may not also be members. A manager-managed structure can be useful when some owners want to invest without taking on daily management responsibilities or when the business has several passive members.

Virginia’s default rule, absent a different provision in the articles of organization or operating agreement, places management with the members. Many states default the same way, though not all of them do, so if your LLC is organized outside Virginia, confirm that state’s default before assuming it applies. Whichever structure you choose, state it explicitly in the operating agreement. Ambiguity about who can sign a contract or open a bank account creates practical problems with vendors, lenders, and landlords.

What Happens When a Member Leaves?

Ownership changes are one reason it is useful to address transfer and buyout provisions in the operating agreement before a change occurs.

Sale or transfer of an interest. A member who wants to sell, whether to a co-owner, an employee, or an outside buyer, needs to know whether the operating agreement requires the other members’ consent, grants a right of first refusal, or restricts transfers outright. Bringing in an outside investor can also raise securities law questions depending on how the interest is offered, which is worth discussing with counsel before any money changes hands.

Death or incapacity. Death or incapacity can affect both the member’s ownership interest and the LLC’s management structure. Virginia law contains specific rules addressing dissociation, assignment, and the rights associated with a membership interest, but the articles of organization and operating agreement significantly affect what happens next.

Divorce. Divorce can also affect an LLC ownership interest or its economic value, depending on applicable equitable distribution laws and the circumstances.

Resignation or removal. An operating agreement can address whether a member may voluntarily withdraw, what happens to their interest if they do, and whether the remaining members can remove a member for specific reasons.

Addressing these scenarios in the operating agreement before they arise gives members a clearer framework for what happens next.

What Should Be in an LLC Operating Agreement?

A well-drafted operating agreement should address:

  • How ownership is measured (percentages or units) and how it can change over time
  • Initial and future capital contributions, and what happens if a member doesn’t contribute as promised
  • Voting rights and which decisions require more than a simple majority
  • How profits, losses, and distributions are allocated
  • Whether the LLC is member-managed or manager-managed, and who can sign on its behalf
  • Transfer restrictions, rights of first refusal, and buyout terms
  • What happens on a member’s death, incapacity, divorce, or resignation
  • How members will resolve a deadlock or serious disagreement
  • Dissolution procedures if the members decide to wind the business down

What New LLC Owners Should Decide Early

Before you and your co-owners finalize your operating agreement, it helps to talk through:

  • How you’ll measure and adjust ownership if someone’s contribution changes over time
  • Whether voting power should match ownership percentage or work differently
  • How and when profits get distributed, and whether any member needs a priority return
  • Who has authority to sign contracts, hire staff, or spend above a certain amount
  • What happens if one of you wants out, or the business needs to bring in a new owner later

Working through these questions before a disagreement arises allows members to make easier decisions down the line.

When Should You Have a Lawyer Review LLC Ownership?

A few moments call for a closer look at your LLC’s ownership structure and documents:

  • You’re adding a new member or investor
  • You’re changing ownership percentages or the profit-sharing formula
  • A member wants to sell, retire, or is going through a divorce
  • You’re preparing the business for a sale or merger
  • Members disagree about management authority or how profits should be split

An operating agreement that was never customized for the business, or that no longer reflects how the business operates, warrants review.

Talk With James River Law About Your LLC Structure

Your operating agreement can provide a framework for ownership, management, distributions, and future changes to the business. Our business law team works with entrepreneurs and business owners across Richmond, Washington, D.C., and New York City to build ownership structures that reflect how a business actually operates. If you’re forming a new company, our business formation attorneys help you evaluate your entity options and establish an appropriate legal structure. If you’re planning for a future transition, our guidance on buy-sell agreements and strategies to prepare your business for sale help you think through that change before it’s underway.

Schedule a consultation with James River Law to talk through your LLC’s ownership structure.

This article provides general information about how LLC ownership typically works and isn’t legal advice. LLC rules vary by state, and the Virginia-specific statutes cited here may not apply to an LLC organized elsewhere. For guidance tailored to your business, talk with a licensed attorney in the state where your LLC is organized.

Please Share!

Stay in the loop!

Sign-up for our newsletter and blog digest and we’ll send you updates with our latest content.

Your future deserves the right legal strategy—let’s start planning now.